Posted by
Bill Lewis on Wednesday, August 02, 2006 5:05:30 PM
Last November there was an alleged massacre of Iraqi civilians by Marines in Haditha. Today, one of the Marines involved in the incident is suing Congressman John Murtha of Pennsylvania for defamation for Murtha's public commentary about the event.
Since May, Murtha has been publicly speaking about Haditha, inferring it was cold blooded murder and that there was a Marine Corps conspiracy to cover up what really happened. Murtha supposedly has his facts of the event from sources in the Pentagon.
As of this writing, the men have not been charged. Once the Marine Corps and the NCIS complete their investigations, the men may be charged, and may be indicted. If indicted they may eventually be found guilty or innocent, but Murtha has declared them guilty long before charges have even been brought.
Murtha was a Marine. So was I. I'm not suggesting Murtha should have kept his mouth shut based on any misplaced loyalties. I am suggesting that he should have noted the presumption of innocence for these young men. If they are guilty, a trial will convict them. If not, Murtha has clearly defamed their character, as well as the character others who served with them.
When Murtha,74, first started speaking on this issue I was confused. At first I chalked it up to his age. Later I realized that he has simply injected his antiwar sentiments into the issue and has lost all perspective along the way. He has become a liberal icon because of this, and that is a pity. He is being used.
If these Marines are guilty of a crime, they should be tried and convicted accordingly. If they are innocent, they should be allowed to live their lives out of the public spotlight. John Murtha has tried and convicted them in his mind, and blasted them and the Marine Corps in public. As a Congressman, he should know better. As a former Marine, he should be ashamed.