Posted by
Bill Lewis on Saturday, July 29, 2006 8:25:01 PM
Editor and Publisher is reporting data from a recent Gallup Poll:
http://www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1002914438According to the poll, 52% of adult Americans want U.S. troops our of Iraq within a year, while 19% want immediate withdrawal. In 1970, poll results were 48% and 23% respectively for a similar withdrawal from Vietnam.
Clearly, there is a loss of public support for the war in Iraq. Just as in Vietnam, things are not going as well as hoped. There is, however, some danger making such comparisons as this poll.
By 1970, the United States had combat troops in Vietnam for five years. By the beginning of that year, over 40,000 Americans had been killed. The time frame of 1965-70 had seen not only the Tet Offensive but also the assassinations of both Bobby Kennedy and Martin Luther King. This country was in a turmoil as it had not seen since the Civil War. There was a military draft.
In 1970, it was almost impossible not to know someone in the military. Today, few members of the public can make such a claim. The public disconnect with the military has never been greater. Far fewer Americans are directly effected by this war than during Vietnam.
Rhetorical cliche's aside, I would really like to know why we are more quickly turning against a war that is far more critical to our continued security than was Vietnam.
We left Vietnam under duress, but the war stayed in Southeast Asia. If we leave Iraq in duress, why would the war not simply follow us home?